My experiences teaching a service-learning composition class entitled Writing Women Safe that dealt with sexual violence against women point to a missing link between course content and community-based activism. Students in my all-female class wrote about and discussed the reality of rape, sometimes in the context of their own lives. However, for all the real talk about a real crime, our well-intentioned service component, the design of informational pamphlets for a rape crisis center, did not draw on students’ personal resources, nor evoke a believable sense of “change agency.” Greater engagement with avenues for action through writing, perhaps via the community partner’s work in the local justice system, as well as deeper reflection on students’ strengths and positioning, are central concerns as I revise my approach to the course.